How to read PPFAS scheme rating reports

From WebNotes, a public knowledge base. Last updated . Reading time ~6 min. Level: Beginner.

This guide covers finding and interpreting third-party scheme rating reports for PPFAS Mutual Fund schemes. The Indian mutual fund industry has three principal rating providers: Value Research Online, Morningstar India, and CRISIL Risk and Return Analysis. Each provider uses a distinct methodology and produces star ratings, peer-comparison metrics, and qualitative analyst commentary. PPFAS schemes typically rate well due to consistent long-term performance and tight risk management, but specific ratings vary across providers and over time.

Step-by-step procedure

Step 1: Visit the rating-provider website

Three primary providers, each accessible via a public-facing scheme search:

  • Value Research Online (valueresearchonline.com): The most widely-read Indian mutual fund research portal. Free access to most basic content; premium subscription for deep analytics.
  • Morningstar India (morningstar.in): Global research firm with India coverage. Free public ratings; subscription for premium analyst reports.
  • CRISIL (crisil.com): Credit-and-research arm of S&P Global; the CRISIL Risk and Return Analysis product provides scheme ratings.

Step 2: Search for the PPFAS scheme of interest

In each provider’s search bar, enter:

  • Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund or PPFCF.
  • Parag Parikh ELSS Tax Saver Fund.
  • Or other PPFAS scheme names.

The scheme detail page loads with rating summary, performance data, and analyst commentary.

Step 3: Locate the rating summary

Each provider’s scheme page typically shows:

  • Current star rating (out of 5).
  • Category (e.g., Flexi Cap for PPFCF).
  • Category rank (e.g., 5 out of 28 in the flexi-cap category).
  • AUM and inception date.
  • Risk-grade (low, moderate, high; some providers use different scales).
  • Returns over various periods (1Y, 3Y, 5Y, 10Y, since inception).
  • Risk-adjusted return metrics (Sharpe, Sortino, alpha, beta versus benchmark and category).

Step 4: Read the rating methodology disclosure

Each provider explains its methodology. Common methodology components:

  • Value Research: Risk-adjusted return-based; specifically, 3-year and 5-year risk-adjusted performance, with weighting based on age of scheme. Star ratings (1 to 5) assigned based on category percentile rank.
  • Morningstar India: Global Morningstar methodology applied to Indian schemes. Uses a 3-pillar framework: People (fund manager), Process (investment philosophy), Parent (AMC). Combines quantitative metrics with qualitative judgement.
  • CRISIL Risk and Return Analysis: Composite score based on mean return, volatility (standard deviation), and downside risk. Star ratings 1 to 5.

Understanding the methodology helps interpret why a scheme may rate differently across providers.

Step 5: Compare ratings across providers

PPFCF may rate differently across providers, often due to methodology differences:

  • Value Research: PPFCF historically rates 4 to 5 stars in flexi-cap category.
  • Morningstar India: PPFCF often receives Silver or Gold analyst rating (Morningstar’s qualitative tier).
  • CRISIL: Star rating based on quarterly analysis.

Cross-provider comparison reveals robustness:

  • Consistently high ratings across providers suggest broad-based quality.
  • Divergent ratings indicate provider-specific methodology effects.
  • Single-provider downgrades or upgrades may reflect short-term volatility rather than fundamental change.

Step 6: Review the peer-comparison data

The rating page shows comparison metrics:

  • PPFCF vs flexi-cap category average: Returns, risk, expense ratio.
  • PPFCF vs top performers in category: Where PPFCF stands.
  • PPFCF vs benchmark (Nifty 500 TRI or similar): Tracking error, alpha generation.

Peer comparison is more diagnostic than absolute rating: a 4-star scheme in a strong category may be more performant than a 5-star scheme in a weak category.

Step 7: Read the analyst’s qualitative commentary

Value Research and Morningstar publish analyst commentary:

  • Value Research: Concise paragraphs on the scheme’s positioning, recent performance, and risk profile.
  • Morningstar India: Detailed analyst report (premium content) covering people, process, parent, and price.

PPFAS schemes often receive commentary highlighting:

  • Fund manager continuity: Rajeev Thakkar has managed PPFCF since launch (24 May 2013).
  • Distinctive philosophy: Overseas allocation, focused portfolio, behavioural-finance lens.
  • Tight risk management: Drawdown control, cash overlay.
  • Lower-than-category-average expense ratio (for direct plan).

Step 8: Cross-check with the PPFAS factsheet

The PPFAS monthly factsheet contains the AMC’s own performance and portfolio disclosure. Cross-check:

  • NAV history: PPFAS factsheet versus rating-provider data.
  • Returns over periods: Should largely agree, with minor differences due to calculation date variations.
  • Expense ratio: AMC-disclosed versus rating-provider-listed.
  • AUM: AMC-disclosed versus rating-provider-listed.

Any material discrepancy should prompt verification; the AMC’s primary disclosure prevails.

See also

External references

References

  1. Value Research Online methodology documentation.
  2. Morningstar India research methodology and analyst-rating framework.
  3. CRISIL Mutual Fund Ratings methodology.
  4. PPFAS Mutual Fund monthly factsheet archive.
  5. PPFAS Mutual Fund, Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund Scheme Information Document.
  6. SEBI Master Circular for Mutual Funds, 22 May 2024.
  7. SEBI Scheme Rationalisation Circular, 2017.
  8. AMFI Industry Best Practices on category framework.
  9. CFA Institute Standards on Investment Performance Reporting.
  10. PPFAS investor desk FAQ at amc.ppfas.com/faqs/.

Reviewed and published by

WebNotes Editorial Team

The WebNotes Editorial Team covers Indian capital markets, payments infrastructure and retail investor procedures. Every article is fact-checked against primary sources, principally SEBI circulars and master directions, NPCI specifications and the official support documentation published by the intermediary in question. Drafts go through a second-pair-of-eyes review and a separate compliance read before publication, and revisions are tracked against the SEBI and NPCI rule changes referenced in the methodology section.

Last reviewed
Conflicts of interest
WebNotes is independent. No relationship with any broker, registrar or bank named in this article.